Season 4 of “That ’70s Show” premiered with an obvious parody of the 1946 film “It’s a Wonderful Life” — going as far as borrowing its title. Much like in the big-screen classic, Eric is visited by an angel (Wayne Knight) who takes him on a trip to the past and future. There he learns what the world would have been like had he and his longtime girlfriend, Donna Pinciotti (Laura Prepon), never shared their first kiss or began dating. Suffice to say, this choice greatly impacted Eric’s life and those of his friends, but at least the whole ordeal was just a dream, right?
According to a fan theory offered by Reddit user KingCollin103, the angel and the events he showed Eric weren’t exactly figments of his imagination. It’s possible that they were entirely real, and Eric actually traveled to the future of a timeline where he and Donna never became an item. As proof, the Redditor cited future Fez’s (Wilmer Valderrama) rendition of “Everybody Have Fun Tonight,” a song that didn’t come out until 1986. This begs the question, “if Eric was just dreaming it up, and the angel wasn’t real, then how did he dream up Fez singing a song that wouldn’t be released until the next decade?”
Screen Rant also notes that other tracks featured in the “It’s a Wonderful Life” episode, such as “The Safety Dance” and “I Ran,” both made their radio debuts in 1982. Therefore, either Eric Forman went on to become a ghostwriter for a handful of iconic ’80s musical groups, or his supposedly fabricated jaunt through time legitimately happened. We’ll leave It up to you to decide.